White Sox banking on Dustin May's untapped upside, and still hunting for more additions
Dustin May set a new career-high with 145⅔ innings this past season, but other than his recent run of good health, the White Sox are banking on him improving upon his statistical track record.

As White Sox general manager Chris Getz led right-hander Dustin May into Rate Field’s conference and learning center to announce his three-year, $52.5 million contract, the back wall was lined with team staffers who would only be familiar if you flipped the media guide to the page listing data engineers and research analysts.

That and bullpen catcher Bennett Markinson, a data science and economics double major from Northwestern. In other words, people who know May’s pitch metrics outstrip his 4.70 ERA from 2026, and would view that figure as a crude way to assess a pitcher.

And not a predictive one.

“He has his best years ahead of him,” Getz declared. It’s not a typical comment to pair with lauding May’s four World Series rings, but it was a shared sentiment.

“My first five seasons, it was very minimal usage,” said May. “To have the last two basically full years, I feel like those were my first two full years in the big leagues. I was honestly still learning and figuring myself out.”

Despite the emphasis on untapping the upside that May’s 97 mph fastball, 6-foot-6 frame and past prospect rankings suggest, the 29-year-old had become a bit of a white whale for Getz. He confessed to unsuccessfully pursuing May last offseason, and this August at the trade deadline.

“He didn’t have a whole lot to say in the matter at the deadline, to my knowledge,” Getz quipped.

For his part, May insisted the persistence wasn’t in vain. After raising his arm slot in 2026 and throwing a cutter more to tamp down the damage lefty hitters have inflicted on him over his career, May indicated the White Sox proposed similar ideas in free-agent conversations last winter, and that he wasn’t shocked by the club’s leap to the postseason.

“I was very close last year, but I think there’s some more untapped things that I could work on,” May said.

Seemingly more progress is needed after May yielded eight homers in 47⅔ innings with the Brewers after being dealt from the Cardinals in August, but the Sox aren’t alone in buying that his avoidance of the injured list this year is further evidence he’s on the right track. Other teams have analysts parsing stuff metrics to hunt upside plays too, and many could fill up more rows of a conference room than the Sox.

A source told the Sun-Times that half the league made inquiries on May at one point, before the field winnowed to a half dozen serious suitors, with the Sox’ winning bid edging three other clubs at the end. As a development project, May spins the baseball like few can, was healthy enough to make 33 starts this year, is ready to “party in the dugout” with his rambunctious new teammates, and was a compelling target to teams — like the White Sox — seeking to identify frontline starters while paying a rate comfortably under what frontline results would demand.

As a solution to the White Sox only having one usable starting pitcher last month, May would look better as part of a multi-prong strategy. Getz affirmed the club is still prowling the starting pitching waters, and he expects to have another addition to tout before the league shuts down late on the night of Dec. 1.

“When this press conference is finished, we are going to continue to get on the phone,” Getz said. “We are very specific in our targets and we know what our needs are and we are going to try to get as much done as we can.”

That’s not going to conclude with the Sox having a fully hashed-out pitching hierarchy two weeks from now, and certainly not with a proven Grant Taylor replacement in place with the bullpen. For now they’re just adding, and it will get figured out later.

“We created the expectation around here that we're going to do whatever we can to win games,” said manager Will Venable. “It starts with getting as many players that you think can help you do that.”

Espace publicitaire · 300×250