Well, that wasn’t fun! Tottenham Hotspur was coming off of three straight wins, something that hasn’t happened in a LONG time, and Tottenham fans, expectedly, got a little excited heading into Saturday’s match against Leeds United at Elland Road.
Oh, my sweet summer children.
It did not go well. Tottenham put in what was probably their second worst performance (behind the Brentford match), lost Mathys Tel to injury (possibly for a while), conceded a second half goal, and lost to Leeds 1-0. It was not pleasant to watch nor to experience. I would rather not talk about it.
But talk about it we must! And apparently that also applies to soccer commentators on American television. If you were unfortunate enough to watch the American feed of this match on USA Network, you were unfortunately subjected to the vapid analysis by Gary and Phil Neville, football siblings who were annoying on the pitch and even more obnoxious off of it. NBC had both Neville brothers on in place of the Two Robbies, and viewers were subjected to a series of absolutely mind-numbing takes. This was “highlighted” by Phil explaining that the Jarrod Bogle tackle on Tel wasn’t a red card because Bogle was apparently “making a normal fullback defensive move” and Tel’s ankle just unfortunately got in the way of his studs-up boot.
Someone in the comments suggested a player ratings theme to “Nevilles” and honestly, it’s a good idea. And I have some takes. So here are the player ratings for Tottenham Hotspur’s loss to Leeds to the theme of Nevilles.
5 stars: Aaron Neville
I mean, just listen to this. Case closed.
Yeah lol there are no Tottenham players in this category.
4 stars: Ashleigh Neville
All hail our former helmet-hair queen of football. Neville was a stalwart Tottenham Women player for nearly a decade. A former primary school teacher, she helped the club promote to the Premier League and was an anchor on the back line. No matter how good Spurs were in those years, Neville was a constant, and at times was Tottenham’s best player under Rehanne Skinner and even Robert Vilahamn. A swashbuckling wingback, she was even deployed higher up the pitch as an attacker at times. Tottenham eventually outgrew her, and she was sold to Leicester City in the summer of 2025; she now plays at Charlton under former manager Karen Hills.
LOL no there are no Tottenham players here either. This match sucked!
3.5 stars: Neville Southall
I was not a Premier League fan when Neville Southall was between the sticks, but I know about him and the enormous influence he had in the game during his playing career. He’s considered one of the best goalkeepers of his generation and among the best of all time, a legend for both Everton where he played for 17 years, and Wales, for which he has 92 caps. He played until he was 45 years old, ending his career at Dagenham & Redbridge. He also had a brief career in management, starting with his appointment as caretaker manager of Wales. One of the greats.
Antonin Kinsky (Community – 4.0): Under a ton of pressure, Kinsky made a couple of outstanding stops, though his distribution in this one was a little shaky.
Jan Paul van Hecke (Community – 3.5): Nobody covered themselves in glory in this match, but on a night where Spurs’ midfield failures put the defense under a lot of pressure, JPVH was quite solid.
3 stars: Sir Neville Marriner
The founder and long-time artistic director of the Academy of St. Martin-in-the-Fields, Sir Neville Marriner was one of the greatest conductors of all time, hugely influential in the classical music world. I am a huge music nerd. Here he is conducting one of the great piano concertos of the western canon, Mozart’s Piano Concerto in D minor.
Mateus Fernandes (Community – 3.0): In the aftermath of the match I called Mateush “Spurs’ best player” on the day, and while I’ve come back slightly from that notion, he was very clearly the best midfielder we had out there. Despite some early minor wobbles, he was the only player maintaining any semblance of control in the midfield and Tottenham collapsed as soon as he went off for Rodrigo Bentancur.
Micky van de Ven (Community – 3.0): A couple of good defensive blocks and clearances, but went unsuccessfully a-rangin’ Chiriches-style a few times in the second half, to Spurs’ detriment.
Mathys Tel (Community – 3.0): One of the few bright(er) sparks in the first half hour of this match when it looked as though Spurs might settle and get something out of this match. Everything fell apart after he went off, but it wasn’t as though he set the pitch on fire either.
Conor Gallagher (Community – 2.5): It’s not like he was super impactful but he had what was probably Spurs’ best scoring chance of the match, and I’d like to at least acknowledge that.
2.5 stars: Neville Longbottom
OK, setting aside all the stuff with Rowling (very temporarily), Neville Longbottom should’ve been the hero of the Harry Potter series. His redemption story from bullied and overlooked child of two wizards tortured by Voldemort to insanity to a capable wizard, resistance leader, and future Hogwarts professor is way more compelling than Harry Potter, who is a middling wizard at best who skates by on his legendary reputation, is bailed out by his friends constantly, and a bleeding idiot. Neville bootstrapped his way up through earned, everyday courage rather than via fame, prophecy or special privileges. You can credibly make a case that Neville did as much or more to arrest the rise of Voldemort than Harry ever did, and without the help of his two best friends every step of the way.
J.K. Rowling still sucks.
Archie Gray (Community – 2.5): OK, I think we can safely say that Archie Gray is not a 10. If this was an experiment, it was a weird time to do that and he didn’t set the world alight. Did okay after being moved to RB.
Mohammed Kudus (Community – 2.5): Absolutely toothless in attack at a time when we needed him to be, well, not that.
Dejan Kulusevski (Community – 2.5): Not really his fault, but he had very little impact on the match after coming on.
2 stars: The (football) Neville Brothers
Look, I just spent the intro lambasting Gary and Phil as know-little pundits with galaxy-brained “former player” takes that favor the large and famous clubs they play for over actual competent tactical analysis. And I hold to that and yet must acknowledge that they aren’t the worst Nevilles out there, just the ones that annoyed me most recently. I will, however, challenge NBC never to do that to us again — one Neville giving bad analysis is bad enough, but BOTH of them? Neville would I ever.
Pedro Porro (Community – 2.5): Gets a bit of a pass as he’s coming back from injury, but he was dreadful in this one, especially defensively. The yellow card was bullshit, though — that tackle was probably the best thing he did all night.
Andy Robertson (Community – 3.0): Awful performance. Lost possession more than anyone else on the team and was a defensive liability.
Sandro Tonali (Community – 3.0): Coming off what might have been his best performance in a Spurs shirt, this one might have been his worst. Terrible in the press, toothless in linking play. A forgettable evening.
Omar Marmoush (Community – 2.0): At this point I really expected a lot more from Marmoush than what we’ve gotten, and he was positively dreadful in this one.
Dominic Solanke (Community – 1.5): I’d give lower if I could but also you don’t ruin the bit.
Rodrigo Bentancur (Community – 2.5): I see people saying he was one of Spurs’ better performers and I just do not see it. Yes, he should’ve replaced Tonali and not Fernandes, and that’s on De Zerbi, but he got cooked so many times by Noah Okafor he could’ve served hotdogs at full time. Also involved in Leeds’ winning goal though nobody covered themselves in glory.
Roberto De Zerbi (Community – 2.0): What the hell was he doing? From the opening kick it looked like Spurs were set up to earn a result not a win, and his substitutions were positively baffling. The players were bad, I put this loss mostly on De Zerbi.
1 star: Neville Chamberlain
Cowardly quisling appeaser. End of.
No Tottenham players were as bad as Neville Chamberlain.
Tom Carroll Memorial Non-Rating
Luca Williams-Barnett









